Last week I visited a few public art sites in Johannesburg and surveyed opinions of and responses to the art from those in the immediate areas. Three distinctly different artworks gave me surprisingly similar results, and made me question the true role of public art. Is public art really intended for the community near which it is placed, is it intended for the so-called “Art Community,” to feel that beautification is happening, or is it for a wider, undefined “community,” and how do we create for that?
Take the Fire Walker, for example. Johannesburg’s “Statue of Liberty” as one headline called it. Designed by William Kentridge and Gerhard Marx, this piece marks the entrance to the CBD as you pass over the Queen Elizabeth bridge. It is in the front of a park, which attracts many people throughout the day, but when sitting in the park you can only see the back of the sculpture.

“Fire Walker,” a woman carrying a brazier on her head in commemoration of the activity which took place in the area in recent years, when ladies would prepare and sell their fires to others preparing food in the surrounding areas. Photo courtesey of Trinity Session.
When I surveyed the people in front of the piece (mostly small entrepreneurs selling sweets and cigarettes), the responses were about the art and about how it made them think and how they would like to create sculptures or use materials in new ways. They enjoyed seeing tourists come and take pictures, and to talk with new people. In contrast, when surveying the majority of the people relaxing in the park in the back, they had barely even taken notice of the piece. There is really no reason to walk to the front of it since it is near the road, and the piece is best viewed by driving past anyways. So it seems the sculpture was intended for the motorists and tourists who had heard about it, and not for the park-visitors.

The piece is located near the bustling Bree Taxi Rank (aka Metro Mall) at the intersection of Newtown, Braamfontein, and the CBD.
Perhaps reactions and responses would have been different if the sculpture had been placed in the center of the park, rather than the front. Maybe then people would view and interact with it on a different level. If raised up in the center, passing cars would still see it and the community might feel that it was actually intended for everyone.

Another view - photo courtesey of JDA
I could be over-analyzing and not taking into consideration a lot of logistics that surrounded the piece. Installed in July 2009, getting the funding and support alone was a great feat. William Kentridge wanted to give a “gift” to his city, and provided his services at minimal costs (comparitively…). Installing a piee of public art in the city, especially one of this magnitude (a budget of over R 1,000,000), means that you usually work with what you have and make sure it gets done.
Unfortunately, this also means that you might be sacrificing potential impact on an area. With workshops or events in the park, or even signs explaining the piece and its significance, a greater buy-in from the community could have the potential to improve community outlook as intended. After surveying people in the park, most asked me to explain the piece to them. People were genuinely interested in what the piece was about. I explained that Kentridge was a very famous artist from Johannesburg, and that a much smaller version of the sculpture had recently sold for over R 1,000,000. The reactions to this were interesting. People looked back at the sculpture and smiled, impressed that something worth so much could be here. It’s crazy how putting a price tag like that on something can change someone’s view so drastically, but that’s another conversation completely.
I feel very strongly that there should be as much public art as possible, and that art does not belong in just museums and galleries. It should be accessible to all. Yet even when art is placed in the public domain, what “public” are we talking about? I’m still looking for the answer, and will write soon about other public art that was developed collaboratively and with community input. But for now, who is the public, and what is the community, and how does art fit in?
Just some thoughts…
Alex
Tags: Africa, art, cities, culture, johannesburg, public art, south africa, william kentridge